Mab of the Antipodes (mab_browne) wrote in fandom_grammar,
Mab of the Antipodes
mab_browne
fandom_grammar

Answer - How do you use "other" versus "else"?

paperbackwriter asked when do you use "other" versus "else"?

Since this comm is Fandom Grammar and no other, what else can I do but use fannish examples to illustrate my answer? This post’s examples come from the characters of The Professionals.


Let's start with some definitions from The Free Dictionary website. Readers will note that other is a busy word.

else
adjective
1.Other; different:
2. Additional; more:
adverb
1. In a different or additional time, place, or manner:
2. If not; otherwise:

other
adjective
1.
a. Being the remaining one of two or more:
b. Being the remaining ones of several:
2. Different from that or those implied or specified:
3. Of a different character or quality:
4. Of a different time or era either future or past:
5. Additional; extra:
6. Opposite or contrary:
7. Alternate; second:.
8. Of the recent past:
noun
1.
a. The remaining one of two or more:
b. others The remaining ones of several:
2.
a. A different person or thing:
b. An additional person or thing:
pronoun
1. A different or an additional person or thing:
2. others: People aside from oneself:
adverb
In another way; otherwise; differently.

One way that potential usage of else and other is clearly different is that else is used as an adjective or adverb, whereas other can also be used as a noun or pronoun.

Bodie chased full tilt after the two men. One turned left, the other turned right, and he had to make a choice as to whether he followed the one in the denim jacket or the one in the truly execrable jumper.

Clearly in this example, substituting else is going to make a nonsense of your sentence.

At first sight, there is overlap between the adjectival uses of else and other. Generally speaking, other can imply 'not this particular thing but that particular thing', while else tends to imply 'not that particular thing but some altogether different thing'.

Doyle was brooding again, and Bodie wasn't going to put up with it. "You need someone to moan to, you find somebody else, mate, not me."

If you wished to use other in this context, you might have Bodie saying "You find someone other than me." Other often takes than to make its distinctions.

Doyle examined the sandwiches in the cabinet. "These look a bit tired, don't they, love," he asked the dispirited girl behind the counter.

"Well, there isn't anything else," she replied.

To use other in this example, the girl might tell Doyle that "There aren't any other sandwiches."

If it had been any other man than Barry Martin to betray CI5, neither Cowley nor Doyle would have taken it so hard.

Using else you might say "If it had been anyone else to betray CI5...."

Sometimes, other is the only choice for the meaning of your sentence.

Leaping out of bed after getting an emergency call on the RT, Bodie could find one sock but not the other.


The adverbial uses of else and other are quite distinct.

Doyle would recover from his injuries, or else he wouldn't.


"Fine, you hate the job," Bodie said. "Where else would you like to be then?"


The Minister made himself difficult to find, and Cowley was unable to see him other than by pursuing him to his club.


Is there anything else to say? In researching this post, I found plenty of discussion as to the nature and use of adverbs and I include some links on the subject in my list of resources.

Definition of else at The Free Dictionary

Definition of other at The Free Dictionary

Else as defined by the MacMillan Dictionary

Other as defined by the MacMillan Dictionary

Adverbs

Parts of Speech

What Is An Adverb

Determiners and Qualifiers
Tags: !answer, author:mab_browne, pos:pronouns, word choice:subtleties
Subscribe

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 2 comments